Share

CLIMATE ACTION PROGRAMME


22 November 2010

World Bank funding of palm oil rousing controversy

The World Bank's proposed easing off on its palm oil strategy has roused relief for corporations worldwide whilst attracting mixed reactions to its plan to finance only firms pursuing green standards.

The revised palm oil strategy of the World Bank is nearing the end of the development stage. It purports financing primary producers of palm oil, prioritising investment to those firms that depend on small farmers for supply and that support sustainable requirements.

The suspension of International Finance Corporation (IFC) funding to the palm oil industry has continued since 2009 due to social and environmental concerns.

Companies worldwide subsequently boycotted the palm oil market. US fast food giant Burger King stopped buying palm oil from Sinar Mas and its subsidiaries after Greenpeace mounted a successful campaign against its land-clearing practices.

Fadhil Hasan, executive director of the Indonesian Palm Oil Producers Association (Gapki), voiced disagreement with the favoured new funding strategy. He said that the jobs created by palm oil producers should be taken into account.

A consortium of indigenous peoples, palm oil smallholders, and non governmental organisations is demanding the World Bank maintains its current freeze on funding the sector until it has a credible strategy to address the sector's manifold problems.

Environmental groups Greenpeace and Sawit Watch support this stance, believing that regulations for meeting environmental criteria should first be met.

Another major issue is that even if the IFC continues withholding funding, palm oil companies are still able to seek private investment for their damaging deforestation operations. Such private companies are considered to be out for profit, with little regard for biological diversity and the effects of climate change.

According to new figures from the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), global production of sustainable palm oil has doubled so far this year. This suggests that buyers with concerns on biodiversity can exploit the supply of palm oil to a higher extent than ever before.

The World Bank's proposed plan to resume funding is good news for a diverse range of industries that use palm oil, from the manufacture of cosmetics and food products, to use in biodiesel.

Since 1965, the World Bank has channelled nearly $2 billion for 45 projects in the palm oil sector in 12 nations across Africa, Latin America and Southeast Asia, according to the company's own figures.

Figures suggest that Indonesia has been a major focus of the financing, receiving $618.8 million of the total investment until funding was ceased in 2009.

Indonesia is the world's largest producer of palm oil despite escalating environmental campaigns, while Malaysia remains the biggest exporter. Indonesia is also the third largest user of palm oil after China and India. The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) currently estimates Indonesian palm oil production in 2010/11 at a record 23.0 million tons, up 2.0 million or 10 per cent from last year. Edible oil supply is dependent on this, with palm oil as the cheapest vegetable oil on the market.

The number of foreign-listed plantation groups in Indonesia has grown rapidly since the early 1990s, with over half of the planted area now owned by private companies. Many have been seeking listing on the Stock Exchange of Singapore (SGX) and the Jakarta Stock Exchange (JSX).

Indonesia is gradually being recognised as the future CPO price benchmark setter instead of Malaysia. This may contribute to increased desire to invest in the market.

With regard to the damage to jobs markets in the developing world, some green groups believe the new investment would create only short term jobs because when global warming continues unchecked, the warmer temperatures will be unfavourable for growing palm oil.

The IFC has taken into account input from almost 3000 stakeholders in its creation of a new framework within the $30 billion palm oil industry.

In the first months of 2011, the framework will be disclosed for 30 days before it is finalised and presented to World Bank President Robert Zoellick for approval.

The World Bank claims to now be in the concluding stages of a multifaceted consultation.

Robert Zoellick was responsible for freezing World Bank Group funding worldwide in the palm oil sector, pending the social and environmental concerns. It is now his responsibility to ensure safeguards are in place to protect all stakeholders.

If the World Bank makes the decision to resume funding, businesses are urged to continue their own assessment on sources of palm oil supply, with regard for land and sustainability of crops. Demand for palm oil has increased across various markets and it is up to all those in the supply chain to ensure healthy growth of the industry. Author: Marianna Keen | Climate Action Image: oneVilliage Initiative/ Flickr

Related Articles

blog comments powered by Disqus

NEWSLETTER

PUBLICATION

Climate Action features expert analysis and opinion and is an essential guide for businesses looking to reduce their carbon footprint

Download Here Find Out More

TWITTER

CLIMATE NEWS
  • Press Releases - Auto industry and motor traders launch clean diesel campaign as Euro 6 comes into force

    Brussels, 1 September 2015 - As of today, all new cars sold must meet the latest EU emissions legislation – Euro 6. To mark this occasion the...

  • ADB, DFID Provide Funding For Pakistan Economic Corridor

    ADB and the Department for International Development (DFID) of the United Kingdom will cofinance the $327 million cost of the 59 kilometer Hassanabdal - Havelian Expressway (E-35) project.

    Pinjaman ADB $400 Juta Bantu Indonesia Ciptakan Sektor Keuangan yang Lebih Inklusif

    ADB telah menyetujui pinjaman program senilai $400 juta untuk membantu Indonesia memperkuat sektor keuangannya, termasuk memperluas akses ke layanan keuangan bagi rumah tangga miskin.

    ADB $400 Million Loan Helps Indonesia Create More Inclusive Finance Sector

    ADB has approved a $400 million program loan to help Indonesia develop its financial sector, including expanding access to financial services for poor households.

    Vanuatu Law Reforms Culminate in Launch of Online Business Registry

    The benefits of a series of legal reforms are set to be realized in Vanuatu, with the opening of an online service that will dramatically simplify the way business is done in the country.

    ADB President Pledges Expanded Support For Fiji and Pacific Islands

    ADB President Takehiko Nakao today met with Fiji Prime Minister Josaia Voreqe Bainimarama.

  • Dynamic discussions at WFC 2015 in Durban? Think CIFOR

    We’re looking forward to some great knowledge exchange with our colleagues from around the world, at the World Forestry Congress...

    A panel of experts discuss landscapes at World Water Week

    [No supplied article summary]

    52nd Annual Meeting of The Association for Tropical Biology and Conservation

    [No supplied article summary]

    Who Pays and Who Benefits? – Side event at SBSTA-42

    [No supplied article summary]

    A Science–Policy Interaction Platform on Forests – Side event at UNFF-11

    [No supplied article summary]

  • EU Bank appoints Mikołaj Dowgielewicz as new EIB Representative to the EU institutions and Head of Brussels office

    The European Investment Bank has appointed Mikołaj Dowgielewicz (43) as the bank’s Brussels Representative with a rank of Director General, to strengthen engagement with institutional and political partners. Mikołaj Dowgielewicz´s previous experience covering foreign affairs, European policy making and multilateral development will make a significant contribution to reinforcing the effective engagement of the European Investment Bank, as Europe’s long-term lending institution. “The EIB is del...

    Jan Vapaavuori is new Vice-President of the EIB

    Jan Vapaavuori has been appointed Vice-President and Member of the Management Committee of the European Investment Bank (EIB). He takes up his duties today, succeeding Wilhelm Molterer, who had tendered his resignation. Mr Vapaavuori, a Finnish national, was appointed by the EIB’s Board of Governors on a proposal from the Finance Minister of the Republic of Finland and with the agreement of the shareholder constituency formed also by Austria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Sweden. In the Bank...

    EIB and Committee of Regions intensify co-operation to boost Europe’s economic recovery

    President of the Committee of Regions (CoR) - Markku Markkula - met with European Investment Bank (EIB) President Werner Hoyer in Luxembourg today to discuss joint efforts to enhance private investment and recovery across Europe. In this context, EIB President Hoyer said: “Cooperation between our institutions is of great benefit for the citizens in Europe. Within the European Union, the Committee of Regions has a very good understanding of local needs and challenges “on the ground”. This help...

    France : 100 millions d'euros pour la rénovation et la modernisation des collèges de Seine et Marne

    Offrir aux jeunes de Seine et Marne des conditions optimales d’éducation et de formation afin de leur donner les meilleures chances de réussite, tel est l’objectif du contrat de financement d’un montant de 100 millions d'euros signé ce mardi 1 er septembre 2015 par Jean-Jacques Barbaux, Président du Département de Seine-et-Marne et Ambroise Fayolle, Vice-Président de la Banque européenne d’investissement (BEI). La cérémonie de signature a eu lieu au collège Lucien Cézard à Fontainebleau, aprè...

    EU Bank intensifies activity in Western Balkan countries

    Werner Hoyer, President of the EIB, announced at the Western Balkans Summit in Vienna a number of projects which the EU Bank is ready to finance in the near future, including the “Rail Route 10” within Kosovo * . Further operations envisaged by the EU Bank include the Trans-Adriatic Pipeline (TAP-project), where EIB launched the initial appraisal. The TAP-project will help diversify gas supply to the European Union and provide an opportunity to develop the use of gas as source of energy in th...

  • Cities and Local Governments Day

    Paris, France

    People´s Climate March

    Paris, France

    City Climate Leadership Award Ceremony

    Paris, France

    UCLG World Council (exact dates tbd)

    Paris, France

    CEMR Annual Meeting (exact date tbd)

    Paris, France

  • IDB selects 15 startups to participate in Demand Solutions program

    IDB chooses 15 startups from Latin America and the Caribbean to take part in Demand Solutions on September 29 in Washington.

    Jamaica will promote economic growth with IDB support

    Jamaica will strengthen its structural program for economic growth with a $130 million loan from the IDB.

    Jamaica launches new electronic procurement system

    The government of Jamaica announced today the launch of the countrys first electronic procurement platform: eTendering System.

    IDB supports energy efficiency and renewable energy schemes in low-cost housing project

    IDB approved a non-refundable financing that will support efficiency and renewable energy schemes in low-cost housing project in Argentina.

    Inter-American Development Bank report highlights business opportunities at the base of the pyramid in Latin America and the Caribbean

    IDB releases report on market at the base of the pyramid in Latin America and the Caribbean, with significant potential for private sector.

  • IISD Refreshes Its Visual Identity

    In the 25 years since IISD was established our mission to promote human development and environmental sustainability has become more urgent. History-making strides have been made to lift billions out of poverty, yet the burden that we place on our natural environment is less sustainable than ever.

    It was with that broad canvas as a back-drop that IISD renewed its strategic plan last year. The result places a tighter focus on six core priorities that meet the critical need for applied sustainability solutions.  



    Underpinning our strategy is a belief that communicating both the vital importance of developing sustainably, as well as the work that IISD is doing in support of that objective, is essential to its success. IISD was a global leader in the use of innovative communication when it was founded, including as an early adopter of Web-based communications. But the communication landscape is moving at speed. So must we.

    A new IISD visual identity, released over the...

    Migration and Conservation in the Lake Albert Ecosystem

    Migration is playing a significant role in the deterioration of the Lake Albert ecosystem in Buliisa District. Migrants, mainly coming from neighbouring provinces in the Democratic Republic of Congo, are pulled to the region by the economic opportunities presented by the fishery, and are willing to work for wages lower than those demanded by the local population. Expanding access to new markets, made possible by infrastructure investments linked to oil and gas exploration, have similarly increased demand for fish from buyers as far away as Kampala. These two forces—increasing demand for fish and increasing supply of labour—have resulted in a fishery dangerously close to collapse: larger species of fish are increasingly rare, while the fish caught are of increasingly smaller size across species. While the implications of this for local livelihoods are significant, current political incentives are aligned with maintaining the status quo. The fishery will continue to...

    Migration and Conservation in the Lake Albert Ecosystem (Policy Brief)

    Migration is playing a significant role in the deterioration of the Lake Albert ecosystem in Buliisa District. Migrants, mainly coming from neighbouring provinces in the Democratic Republic of Congo, are pulled to the region by the economic opportunities presented by the fishery, and are willing to work for wages lower than those demanded by the local population. Expanding access to new markets, made possible by infrastructure investments linked to oil and gas exploration, have similarly increased demand for fish from buyers as far away as Kampala. These two forces—increasing demand for fish and increasing supply of labour—have resulted in a fishery dangerously close to collapse: larger species of fish are increasingly rare, while the fish caught are of increasingly smaller size across species. While the implications of this for local livelihoods are significant, current political incentives are aligned with maintaining the status quo. The fishery will continue to...

    Migration and Conservation in the Bale Mountains Ecosystem

    Human migration is playing a significant role in driving land conversion and sustaining the overexploitation of key natural resources in the Bale Mountains ecosystem, to the detriment of conservation and traditional livelihoods. A similar process of land conversion is taking place in the absence of an influx of migrants, albeit at a much slower pace, and the ecosystem is under threat from a variety of factors, including population growth, changing climate conditions, and shifting livelihood strategies and socioeconomic expectations of the resident population. But in a context of rapid socioeconomic change and escalating internal population pressures, migration accelerates and intensifies the livelihood changes and associated land conversion processes that are inevitable in the long term. This will continue, unless effective and sustainable resource management systems are put in place.

    This report presents an assessment of the migration context in the Bale Mountains ecosystem, as...

    Migration and Conservation in the Bale Mountains Ecosystem (Policy Brief)

    Human migration is playing a significant role in driving land conversion and sustaining the overexploitation of key natural resources in the Bale Mountains ecosystem, to the detriment of conservation and traditional livelihoods. A similar process of land conversion is taking place in the absence of an influx of migrants, albeit at a much slower pace, and the ecosystem is under threat from a variety of factors, including population growth, changing climate conditions, and shifting livelihood strategies and socioeconomic expectations of the resident population. But in a context of rapid socioeconomic change and escalating internal population pressures, migration accelerates and intensifies the livelihood changes and associated land conversion processes that are inevitable in the long term. This will continue, unless effective and sustainable resource management systems are put in place.

    This policy brief summarizes an assessment of the migration context in the Bale Mountains...

  • Auctions Emerge as Key Instrument to Promote Renewable Energy

    El Salvador’s National Energy Council recently announced plans to auction 150 MW of renewable energy projects. Brazil awarded contracts to the developers of 669.5 MW of clean energy capacity last week in its latest auction. And the ACT government in Australia has launched its second large-scale wind farm auction, which is expected to double the … Continue reading Auctions Emerge as Key Instrument to Promote Renewable Energy

    Saving Power for Rainy Days

    As rapid cost reductions for renewable energy technologies drive an energy transition across the globe, one fundamental question remains regarding a future powered by renewables: “What about when the sun doesn’t shine and the wind doesn’t blow?” Electricity storage is often positioned as THE solution to the problem of variable (i.e. not consistent) power generation from solar … Continue reading Saving Power for Rainy Days

    Energy Efficiency Vital to Doubling Global Share of Renewables

    It may sound obvious that efforts to scale-up renewable energy and efforts to improve energy efficiency are interlinked. We consume less energy overall when we implement energy efficiency measures like installing building insulation or efficient lighting. In parallel, as we add more renewable energy to the world’s energy mix, the share of renewable vs. non-renewable … Continue reading Energy Efficiency Vital to Doubling Global Share of Renewables

    Pacific Island Countries and Territories Explore Ways to Transform Energy Systems

    “What is the utility business model after all? It’s making returns on assets. And moving from fossil fuels to renewables will increase the asset base and the actual value of the utility, increasing its revenues.”- Dutch Kuyper, Parker Ranch In explaining the sound business case for transitioning traditional utilities to renewable energy, Dutch Kuyper of … Continue reading Pacific Island Countries and Territories Explore Ways to Transform Energy Systems

    REthink Energy on the Road to Paris

    In the lead up to the United Nations Climate Change Conference (COP 21), 30 November – 11 December in Paris, we are encouraging our readers to REthink energy. The energy sector accounts for more than two thirds of global greenhouse-gas emissions. Under current policies and national plans, carbon dioxide emissions will not fall enough to avoid … Continue reading REthink Energy on the Road to Paris

  • Regional Development Forum for Asia-Pacific held in Bangkok

    The ITU Regional Development Forum (RDF) for Asia and the Pacific was held in Bangkok, Thailand on 21 and 22 August 2015 under the theme “Smartly Digital Asia-Pacific”. The Forum was attended by about 100 participants from over 31 Member...

    ITU Distributes Trend Micro 2Q 2015 Security Roundup

    In line with the collaboration between ITU and Trend Micro, with an objective to facilitate sharing of relevant cybersecurity material and enhance cybersecurity awareness of Member States, ITU is distributing the Trend Micro 2Q roundup report for 2015. Titled ‘A...

    Communiqué: ITU deploys emergency communication equipment in Myanmar

    International relief effort underway in aftermath of widespread floods Geneva, 18 August 2015 – ITU has deployed emergency telecommunication equipment in Myanmar following severe floods which have claimed many lives and submerged more than 200,000 acres of farmland, damaging essential infrastructure and...

    Meet the winners of the #speakstandards video competition

    A team of four from Mexico has won first prize in the #speakstandards video competition. Their video highlighting the importance of standardized graphical symbols in our daily life received half of the nearly 6,500 public votes. The #speakstandards video competition challenged people...

    Press Release : ITU announces Telecom World Entrepreneurship Awards

    Award to recognize small businesses and entrepreneurs using innovative ICT solutions for social good Geneva, 11 August 2015 – ITU has launched the ITU Telecom World Entrepreneurship Awards 2015, a new awards programme for the most innovative start-ups, micro-, small and medium-sized businesses...

  • Michigan Governor Rick Snyder Announces Process for Tackling Carbon Pollution Under the Clean Power Plan

    Governor Rick Snyder’s administration announced today that Michigan would develop a state implementation plan to achieve carbon pollution reductions set by the federal Clean Power Plan. 

    Groups File Notice of Intent to Sue EPA Over Dangerous Drilling and Fracking Waste

    WASHINGTON, D.C.  (August 26, 2015) – A coalition of environmental organizations filed a legal notice with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency today demanding regulations to stop oil and gas companies from dumping drilling and fracking waste in ways that threaten public health and the environment.

    NRDC Turns Up Pressure on Subway to Disclose Antibiotic Use in Meat Production

    WASHINGTON D.C. (August 26, 2015) – As Subway marks its 50th anniversary later this week, the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) today launched a national campaign urging Subway, the world’s largest fast food chain by number of locations, to publicly commit to phasing out the purchase of meats raised with the routine use of antibiotics. Many of Subway’s competitors, including McDonalds, Chick-Fil-A, Chipotle and Panera Bread, and others, have announced major initiatives to eliminate routine use of antibiotics by their suppliers, leaving Subway far behind the pack.  

    Report: Significant Energy Efficiency Savings Available to Ohioans for Years to Come

    CHICAGO (August 26, 2015) – A new study finds there is huge potential in Ohio to save families and businesses money on their utility bills through energy saving programs. This study by the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy (ACEEE), which examines reports from Ohio utilities as well as industry-standard programs that Ohio has yet to take into account, concludes the state has significant, cost-effective, and untapped energy efficiency potential just waiting to be utilized.

    New Jersey Court Approves Bad Deal Between Christie Administration & ExxonMobil Over Decades of Oil Refinery Pollution

    MOUNT HOLLY, N.J. (August 25, 2015) – A New Jersey court today approved a settlement between ExxonMobil and Governor Chris Christie’s administration over damages due for decades of toxic soil and water contamination in the northern part of the state. The settlement gives the oil giant a more than 98 percent discount on the state’s original price tag for restoring and replacing the resources.

  • Corporate WASH pledge helps 1.6 million people gain access to safe water, sanitation and hygiene

    [No supplied article summary]

    Sustainable Procurement Guide

    Informed procurement choices can support the sustainable management of forests, help protect workers’ health and the rights of the people who depend on forests. Growing numbers of private and public sector actors are setting ambitious targets to eliminate deforestation from their supply chains. The question remains: How to implement and deliver on these commitments?

    From waste to opportunity: Over 20 companies launch new project to scale up material reuse across US facilities

    [No supplied article summary]

    Raising the bar for the forest products value chain

    [No supplied article summary]

    Land degradation neutrality: Why this should be on top of the business agenda

    [No supplied article summary]