International Year of Forests - 2011 2012 International Year of Sustainable Energy For All

News and Analysis  >  News  >  Boundaries between science and policy blurred, says scientific advisor

24 February 2011 | Luca Del Buono
Climate Change, Australia

 

Tension between the Australian government and its chief scientist was exposed on Wednesday (23 February) with revelations she was not asked for advice before a world climate change conference.

Scientist Penny Sackett, whose shock resignation halfway through a five-year term was announced last week, told a Senate hearing that she had never met Prime Minister Julia Gillard; neither had she been invited to the United Nations Climate Change Conference in Copenhagen in 2009 to assist with negotiations or advise on the science.

Sackett said she is confident that all her advice ''has been considered”; however she was not called on in the lead-up to the climate change conference to give advice on emissions targets. She told the hearing that she briefed former Prime Minister Kevin Rudd only once during his tenure.

The scientific advisor said the function of chief scientist is unclear. ''A decision has to be made by the government to set the boundaries for what it would like to be achieved in the role,'' she said.

''Scientists must communicate but be clear when they are talking about science and when they are talking about policy,'' she told the senate economics legislation committee. Boundaries between science and policy are being blurred, she said.

While science is ''not the complete answer'' it provides evidence to help in making decisions, she added.

Science Minister Kim Carr said he met Professor Sackett about once a month. ''Through those and other meetings she has provided advice to government on a wide range of issues,'' he said.

However, opposition science spokeswoman Sophie Mirabella said the relationship is flawed: "If the Prime Minister doesn't even meet with you and you're supposed to be her chief adviser on science – that shows a pretty rude disregard.

"What is surprising is the Government set this office up; it employs 16 people and costs $2.3 million a year. Why wouldn't you use those resources?"

Sackett told the committee: ''It is my firm view that all countries should immediately seek ways to reduce global greenhouse gas emissions and prepare for the effects of climate change that are already under way and those that we expect from emissions already in the atmosphere,'' adding that Australia will be at an economic disadvantage if action is delayed.

Image: Πρωθυπουργός της Ελλάδας | Flickr

blog comments powered by Disqus

Climate Action 2011

Climate Action 2011

Know what actions industry leaders and climate change experts suggest to reduce carbon footprints and mitigate climate change - read the 2011 edition of Climate Action

Corporate Partners

  • Advanced Plasma Power Orona
  • Talesun RVE.SOL
  • Lorentz BearingPoint
  • Sovello Kaneka
  • Solar Nexus International Wonderbag
  • Photon Energy IDE Technologies Ltd
  • AEG Power Solutions Agrinos
  • RISO Nedbank
  • Anglo American Comision Nacional del Agua (CONAGUA)
  • Agro america The Building and Construction Authority (BCA)
  • Solaire direct ESRI
  • Raizen EDF Energy
  • Schneider Electric Brasil foods
  • Barloworld Natureworks
  • Keppel land Zorlu Energy Group
  • Fredericia Kommone - municipality Autodesk
  • Exxaro SCA
  • Bombardier Piotrans
  • Eisenmann African International Energy
  • Suntech CEMIG
  • New Holland Scania
  • VSHydro Blackberry
  • MTN Orange
  • Suzlon

White Papers

Climate Action Partners with NatureWorks for COP-16Climate Action Partners with NatureWorks for COP-16

Climate Action partnered with NatureWorks, maker of the Ingeo™ biopolymer, at COP 16.

Energy from Waste Conference

Efficiently utilising residual waste has become an issue of great importance recently.


More White Papers...

Press Releases

Nick Nuttall, UNEP Spokesperson officially opens Sustainable Innovation Expo receptionNick Nuttall, UNEP Spokesperson officially opens Sustainable Innovation Expo reception

For the third time, Climate Action, in partnership with the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP), showcased the latest sustainable technological innovations and services to an international audience of government officials and environmental professionals at the 12th Special Session of the Governing Council and Global Ministerial Environment Forum (GC/GMEF) of the United Nations Environment Programmeon the 20-22nd February in Nairobi, Kenya.

New Holland’s online CarbonID™  calculatorNew Holland’s online CarbonID™  calculator

New Holland has developed a carbon footprinting method which enables farmers and contractors to calculate the carbon footprint of their current tractor fleet.


More Press Releases...

Supporters